1821 Info11f3 for Walter John Thomas Blackman (Tom)
Fifty years in psychiatric care



Introduction - a timeline

After the Battle of Polygon Wood, on 26 September 1917, Tom was admitted to Central Training School, Havre; the general Base Depot for all five Australian Divisions. Two weeks later, on 17 October 1917, he was transferred to 2nd General Hospital, [Le] Harve as a patient N[ot] Y[et] D[iagnosed] 1. Tom’s service record for 28 October 1917 records Embarked for Eng: [HMAT A69] “Warilda” 2nd Lt Adm. 4th Lon Gen Hosp P.U.O. 2 This was the beginning of his treatment for shell-shock

Map of Le Harve c.1914 - 80kB jpg Map of Le Harve c.1914 - 80kB jpg There are two locations given for 2nd General Hospital: in early December 1914 they took over Palais des Régates and then over Gare Maritime on Quai d’Escale 2 circled.

Left: A pre-war map of Le Harve showing the location of 2nd General Hospital Source: Long Long Trail

Click on the map to open a scalable pdf map in a new window

Hoverbox Photo Gallery - 2nd General Hospital le Havre
This feature does not function correctly on phones and tablets

1 The Palais des Régates, next to the sea in the Sainte Adresse area of Le Havre   2 Ward 4 of No 2 General Hospital on the Quai D'Escale after the armistice AWM H11833
1   2  
Palais des Régates - 41kB jpg Palais des Régates - 41kB jpg Ward 4 of No 2 General Hospital - 38kB jpg Ward 4 of No 2 General Hospital - 38kB jpg

In February 1915, Charles Myres, 3 4 a psychologist who wrote the first paper on shell-shock in 1915, put a psychiatric facility closer to the front line at Le Touquet. In December 1916, Myres was authorised to establish four specialist units for acute or mild cases of shell-shock, whilst chronic and severe cases were sent to London. 4 Was there a Meyres’ unit at the large Le Havre base to diagnose Tom as a chronic or severe case to be sent to London?

1821info11f3, sheet 2
HMHS Warilda 1917 - 18kB jpg On 27 October 1916, Tom was transferred from Le Havre to England on the hospital ship Warilda classified as a casualty with PUO, which figures prominently in Tom's immediate future.

Left: HMHS Warilda having been camouflaged in 1917 AWM A02847 On 3 August 1918 Warilda was torpedoed and sunk off Le Havre with the loss of 125 lives.

End notes

  1. NAA Repatriation p.245
  2. Pyrexia [fever] of Unknown Origin is classified as: patients included in this syndrome will be more difficult to diagnose as they have already resisted classification during baseline investigations. Clinical Perspectives: Pyrexia of unknown origin: causes, investigation and management (Accessed: 05 November 2019) A failure to reach a diagnosis after one week of inpatient investigation.
  3. Captain Charles Samuel Myers CBE, FRS Psychiatrist to the Forces in France
  4. American Psychological Association (Accessed: 05 November 2019)
  5. Long Long Trail (Accessed 05 November 2019)

Treatment in the Fourth London Territorial General Hospital and Maudsley Wing

By 1916, the ambulance trains of World War 1 were sophisticated but slow means of transporting casualties to base hospitals on the coast of France or on to England. Each of these ‘khaki’ ambulance trains, as opposed to the more primitive French ‘green’ trains, was a community on wheels staffed by experienced nurses and orderlies, a team for each self-sufficient carriage. Generally, casualties were well cared for.

Often attached to the rear were supplementary unmarked grey carriages, looking like supply wagons, solely for the use of mental cases who had to be kept in confinement.

On arrival in London the ambulance train casualties became the responsibility of the London Ambulance Column who, nightly, ferried the wounded to the many London hospitals. Casualties from the grey-wagons were unloaded, once the rest of the train had been emptied and the crowds had gone home, into a fleet of unmarked grey ambulances parked down a side road. 1

Was this Tom’s experience on his journey from Harve to the 4th London?

On 28 October 1917, Tom was fortunate in being an officer who was transferred to the Maudsley Ward of the Fourth London Territorial General Hospital.

1821info11f3, sheet 3
At the beginning of the War, the National Hospital for the Paralysed and Epileptic, 2 known as Queens Square, had gained an international reputation for the treatment of neurological disorders including shell-shock. The new Maudsley Memorial Wing was formed in the Fourth London Territorial General Hospital which was located in the newly completed Kings College Hospital, 3 The Maudsley had 400 specialist beds in neurology for psychiatric casualties. 4

Right: Kings College Hospital Wellcome Collection M0003165 (CC BY 4.0)
Kings College Hospital - 32kB jpg
Frederick Walker Mott - 25kB jpg Left: Major later Col. Sir Frederick Walker Mott 1917 (National Portrait Gallery)

The prevailing theory was, if not physically unfit soldiers were mental cases and cowards. 5 Treatment was a lottery. It varied from cutting edge psychiatry to quackery and neglect, punishment and a firing squad. The Government attitude changed from treatment to containment, and punishment, the classification of desertion and court martial. Though hospital treatment may have seemed severe, it was less severe than the tough military stance on shell-shock.
After the Somme there were many patients who could not be categorised into casualties. However, soldiers could only enter treatment with profound physical symptoms associated with explosions known as 'commotional' shock.

In January 1916, Major Frederick Walker Mott established the Maudsley Receiving Centre for chronic cases of shell-shock coming from France. The Maudsley took ‘all unwounded cases suffering from neurasthenia 6, functional paralysis, hysteria and the milder psychoses’. 7

Mott gathered hard, scientific evidence that physically fit, well trained and well lead soldiers who were exposed to horrendous events would break down. He began to lift the blanket of shame and stigma of shell-shock by researching treatments: continuous warm baths for muscle relaxation and sleep induction; improved nourishment; pain relief; quiet rest; simple games and light occupation. His use of pioneering occupational and talking treatment with pastoral care and rehabilitation: now the basis for modern psychiatry. 8 However, the advances made by Mott were not being replicated throughout the country. 9

1821info11f3, sheet 4

Despite there being no surviving Maudsley case records, Tom was lucky to come under Mott's care. However, Mott's treatment was unsuccessful.

End notes

  1. Mayhew, Emily, Wounded From battlefield to Blighty 1914-1918, The Bodley Head, London, 2013 p.207
  2. National Hospital for the Paralysed and Epileptic, Queens Square, Holborn, London WC1
  3. Kings College Hospital, Bessemer Road, Denmark Hill, Brixton, London SE5.
  4. In early 1918 the Maudsley became independent and was known as the Neurological Clearing Hospital taking the majority of neurological cases from overseas.
  5. He embraced the opportunity to study the effects of explosives on the central nervous system having observed, in more than one autopsy, the brain's of soldier’s who had died without signs of physical injury. Mott found evidence of cell death and small bleeds in the brain’s white matter and concluded the changes must have been caused by the enormous force of compression and decompression of high explosives in great shells (concussion). (Linden p.73)
  6. Characterized by fatigue and lassitude, with vague physical symptoms such as headache, muscle pain, and subjective sensory disturbances, originally attributed to weakness or exhaustion of the nerves and later considered a form of neurotic disorder. (Oxford English Dictionary - OED) A well-respected officer diagnosis for anxiety, exhaustion, pain, palpitation and digestive problems, as opposed to ‘hysteria’. (Linden p.94, 115)
  7. Severe mental illness, loss of contact with reality (in the form of delusions and hallucinations) and deterioration of intellectual and social functioning, occurring as a primary disorder or secondary to other diseases. (OED)
  8. Linden pp.73, 209
  9. The War Office, in the need for men at the front. needed quick cures and turn round. In 1917, Arthur Hurst was a physician, and not psychiatrist, at the Royal Victoria Hospital at Netley producing cures in a short period of time. However, though he filmed his patients before and after, he was vague about his methods. Whilst there appeared to be instant recovery, it is believed that the films were taken at different times so they were not the alleged instant solutions and many patients relapsed. Shell-shock brought mental health into the open. The 1922 Report of the War Office Committee of enquiry into ‘shell-shock’ recorded:

Latchmere House for 'insane' officers

Tom was transferred to Latchmere House 1 on 29 January 1918. During World War 1, Latchmere House, a Victorian mansion, was taken over by Lord Knutsford's committee and opened in November 1915 as a Special Hospital for (Army) Officers. An order was issued that insane officers should be sent to Latchmere. 2 Until additional accommodation was built in 1917, admissions were limited to 51 beds. By the end of the war some 95 psychotic officers had been treated at Latchmere 3. This limited number suggests the severity of Tom’s case.

Right: Latchmere House from Latchmere Lane
Lachmere House from Latchmere Lane - 63kB jpg
1821info11f3, sheet 5

Tom's Latchmere House assessment record the first details of his injuries. It summarises thirteen months of treatment, prior to repatriation in March 1919, and records:

Patient behaved strangely while in France & was sent to England & admitted to Maudsley Ward, 4th London General Hospital for observation & transferred thence to Latchmere House 29.1.18 where he has been since in an insane state. This was attributed to the strain and stress of service. He had a nervous breakdown when 21 years old and prior to enlistment from which he recovered. 5

It records the important predisposition and relevant nervous breakdown in 1909 at the age of 21, whilst at Mt Hooghly or Leneva Schools. Tom’s present condition was described as:

He is mute, refuses food, has been tube fed for 1 year absolutely refusing food. Will occasionally take food from ladies who have visited him. He will sometimes speak to them. He is delusional. He is insane 4. [My emphasis] He vigorously resists tube feeding. 5

He was assessed as having a permanent disability making him unfit for further military service and was recommended for close attention & observation in a Mental Hospital with the constant attention of another person.

1821info11f3, sheet 6
 Tom Blackman's Latchmere House medical - 1882kB jpg
Above: A composite image of Tom Blackman's Latchmere House medical
1821info11f3, sheet 7
HMHS Karoa 1915 - 24kB jpg On 28 February 1919, Tom embarked on HMHS Karoa, identified as a mental patient, 6 for repatriation to Melbourne, Australia arriving 08 May 1919.

Left: HMHS Karoa 1915

End notes

  1. Lost Hospitals of London - Special Hospital for Officers, Latchmere (Accessed: 05 November 2019) Located at Church Road, Ham Common, Richmond, Surrey, TW10 5HH. In July 1940 this became Camp 020 under the command of MI5's Major RWG Stephens. Here Nazi spies and suspect refugees were interrogated, including Codename Garbo for the Double Cross system. In the cold War Camp 020 interrogated Eastern Block 'stay behind' agents before being replaced by two centres. Twigge, Hampshire and Macklin, British Intelligence, The National Archives, London, 2009
  2. Psychoneurotic but not insane officers were sent to Lord Knutsford's other hospital for shell-shocked officers at Palace Green. Psychoneurosis: Characterized by anxiety, depression, or other feelings of unhappiness or distress that are out of proportion to the circumstances of a person's life. Repressed unconscious conflict or fantasy (OED)
  3. After the War, the Hospital came under the control of the Ministry of Pensions and had, from 1935 until 1939, twenty beds for severely disabled officers. During World War 2 Latchmere was a special MI5 interrogation centre, codenamed Camp 020, for British Blackshirts. In 1948 Latchmere was taken over by the Prison Service of the Home Office, who used it variously as a junior and senior detention centre. In 1992 it became a resettlement prison. It is now HMP Latchmere House, with accommodation for 207 prisoners.
  4. Not of sound mind, mad, mentally deranged. Mad, idiotic, utterly senseless, irrational. (OED)
  5. NAA Repatriation pp.223-4
  6. NAA Service record p.24

1821info11f3, sheet 8

Care in Ballarat and Melbourne - a timeline


An assessment at the Military Mental Hospital, Royal Park, Melbourne

On 22 August 1919, Tom was assessed at the Military Mental Hospital, Royal Park. 1 This was a short stay assessment and confinement before being discharged on 26 August 1919.

Hoverbox Photo Gallery - Locating Royal Park Hospital, Melbourne
This feature does not function correctly on phones and tablets

1 Royal Park Mental Hospital buildings
Source: Victoria Heritage Database
  2 Map locating the now demolished Royal Park
Mental Hospital 2019
1   2  
Royal Park Mental Hospital buildings - 50kB jpg Royal Park Mental Hospital buildings - 50kB jpg Map locating Royal Park Mental Hospital - 35kB jpg Map locating Royal Park Mental Hospital - 35kB jpg

Hoverbox Photo Gallery - Royal Park Mental Hospital 2012 not necessarily 1919 era
This feature does not function correctly on phones and tablets

1 West wing   2 North wing
1   2  
Royal Park mental hospital 2012 - 34kB jpg Royal Park mental hospital 2012 - 34kB jpg Royal Park mental hospital 2012 - 25kB jpg Royal Park mental hospital 2012 - 25kB jpg

Tom’s assessment at Royal Park on 22 August 1919 concluded that his disorder resulted from Active Service in France. This is relevant to later claims made on the Government for Death Duties. The report describes in more detail the cause of his injury and his present state at Royal Park:

1821info11f3, sheet 9
Buried by a shell explosion. Nearly smothered, and not found for some time. Dazed and confused afterwards. Is now quiet, reticent, apparently in a "dream" state from which he rouses himself when spoken to. Has a dull expression and a vacant look although he replies readily to all questions. Never occupies or amuses himself. Caused by shell shock, acting on a constitution predisposed to psychosis on active service. 2 He is dreamy to a pathological degree, anergic 3 and mildly demented. 4
[At the time of the assessment Tom wa] dull, anergic, incapable of taking an interest in his case or his environment; indisposed to initiate conversation, even to the extent of a remark or a comment. The Board attributed these conditions to Emotional shock, acting on a predisposed nervous temperament. He was to be discharged as permanently unfit, unable to earn his living and requiring further Treatment in a suitable Institution; being recommended for General treatment; isolation and observation. 4

The document was signed by W. Ernest Jones Lt.Col. President 5: the man behind the Melbourne Lunacy reforms and principles of the Mont Park Hospital for the Insane. He was another major reformer in Tom's treatment of shell-shock, 'lunacy' and the ' insane'. Tom was discharged from Royal Park on 26 August 1919.

In reference to your 19/8869 of 9th September, regarding Lieut Blackman, this Department is advised by its Medical experts in Mental diseases that whilst the recovery of Lieut Blackman is of course not impossible, yet it is improbable at any rate for a very long time. Hence he is certified by this Department as incurable. Would you please take the necessary action for the treatment of this officer after discharge. 6
Royal Park medical - 66kB jpg
Above: A composite image of Tom's Royal Park medical report 4

This diagnosis, confirming the findings of 4th Territorial and Latchmere House certified Tom's future in the care of the Repatriation Board and its State and Commonwealth successors through to his death .

1821info11f3, sheet 10

End notes

  1. In September 1907, the Royal Park Receiving House opened in Park Street, Parkside, Melbourne, providing short-term diagnosis and treatment for patients before a patient was transferred to a Hospital for the Insane - at the time it was the only Receiving House in Victoria under the 1903 Lunacy Act. No person was to be detained for more than two months. In April 1909 the Royal Park Hospital for the Insane opened on the same site, providing long- term patients with accommodation and treatment. The Mental Hygiene Act 1933 altered the title of all ‘Hospitals for the Insane’ to ‘Mental Hospitals', hence it became the Royal Park Mental Hospital.
  2. NAA Repatriation p.197 Stephanie Linden’s finding would argue that the nervous breakdown in 1909 made Tom predisposed to psychosis on active service and a predisposition for the final breakdown and perhaps the Gallipoli repatriation. Tom's Freedom of Information file records his mother having a breakdown years before
  3. A lack of mental energy, debility, passivity (OED)
  4. NAA Repatriation p.197
  5. In 1905, Dr (William) Ernest Jones was appointed Victoria ‘Inspector General of the Insane’, with the aim to change the overcrowding and inadequate staffing in Victoria’s mental hospitals. He was responsible for constructing much of Mont Park, emphasising the benefits for the hospital, staff and patients of open grounds, fresh air and productive activities. During WWI Jones, holding the honorary rank of Lieutenant-Colonel, was involved with many of the returning mentally ill veterans. In 1918, at Mont Park, Jones introduced the returned servicemen to Occupational Therapy, to assist rehabilitation, by training them as carpenters, saddlers, tailors to name a few. The distinctive white Spanish Mission style Ernest Jones Hall recognised his contribution to Victoria’s mental health system from 1905 to 1937. Mont Park to Springthorpe (Accessed: 1 November 2019)
  6. NAA Repatriation p.193

Care after discharge from Royal Park

Tom was discharged to 12 Baird Street Ballarat, into the care of his parents and the local Ballarat Repatriation Department. On 13 October 1919, Dr Walter Barker, its medical consultant, visited Tom and reported:

He was clean, neat and recently shaved, and his mother states that he is able to look after himself perfectly in such respects, and to dress unaided. He set his lips firmly and no persuasion on my part would induce him to speak, or to express in any way his consciousness that he was being addressed. His mother believes he is silent because he is unable to remember the words he requires, and on the few occasion he has spoken since his return, he has seemed to find this difficulty (sic) but on the other hand he has welcomed his sister and spoken appropriately to the occasion. … I would suggest his return to Mont Park for observation and special treatment. 1

Right: Copy of the Ballarat report

1821info11f3, sheet 11
Tom Blackman with grandpa William Blackman - 29kB jpg Left: Tom Blackman with William Blackman at an unknown date, perhaps 1919. Tom is in uniform so he may not have been discharged and he is wearing his 'Pip', 'Squeak' and 'Wilfred' medal ribbon. His medals were not dispatched to Baird Street until circa 1921.

On 13 October 1919 the Ballarat Local Repatriation Medical Officer, Col. C.H.Wm. Hardy, recommended that Tom be escorted to Mont Park. The authorisation to be admitted to No. 16 Australian General Hospital (AGH), Mont Park was written on 19 November 1919. By the 28 November 1919 he had not reported. On 23 December 1919, in a letter to the Master of Lunacy, Lt. Col. Dr. Ernest Jones, it was stated that Tom was too ill to travel to Melbourne and was placed in the Ballarat Receiving Home. Tom was a certified patient under the Mental Treatment Act with the Repatriation Department accepting the responsibility for his maintenance at 6/- (six shillings) a day. However, on 19 February 1920 Corporal J Antcliff was issued an 8/3 (8 shillings and 3 pence) return rail warrant to escort Tom to Melbourne and the Military Ward at Mont Park. 2

The Repatriation Department continued to pay monthly bills submitted by the Mental Ward of No.16 AGH Mont Park through to January 1925 and possibly September 1927.

End notes
  1. NAA p.177
  2. ibid pp. 157, 160, 162, 170, 172, 173

1821info11f3, sheet 12

Life at Mont Park and Bundoora Repatriation Hospitals - a time line

An introduction to Mont Park and Bundoora Repatriation Hospitals is shown below allowing Tom to slot into both at different times in his long life within the Veteran Rehabilitation system.


1821info11f3, sheet 13

Admission to Mont Park

Mont Park admission register page 1 - 42kB jpg
Above: The left hand page of Tom's admission to Mont Park
Mont Park admission register page 2 - 30kB jpg
Above: The right hand page of Tom's admission to Mont Park
Source: PROV VPRS 18142 Admission and Discharge Register of Patients (Mont Park Psychiatric Hospital) (Not available on-line)

The Mont Park admission register shows that Tom was patient 258 admitted on 8 May 1919. It gives his rank and battalion. No other details are recorded.

Whilst George McKenzie and Bertram Swift were discharged in 1919, Toms wasn't discharged. Instead there are dates in the 'Remarks' column: 29.7.24, 7.3.29 and 21.9.30. Each date is preceded by an 'Ex' and is followed by an 'R' and another date. The September 1930 date corresponds to an 'absent without leave' (see below).

Tom's medical records for Mont Park and Bundoora will be available under a Freedom of Information release. Until then, the Repatriation Medical Record will give a flavour of Tom's treatment and life in care.

1821info11f3, sheet 14

A short history of Mont Park

The development of Mont Park and Bundoora charts Tom's post-war life which started at Mont Park Repatriation Hospital, continued through to Bundoora Repatriation Hospital and involved reassessment at Mont Park.

1946 map of Mont Park - 61kB jpg 1946 map of Mont Park - 61kB jpg
Above: A 1946 map of Mont Park with the approximate position of the main building highlighted in red Source: Greensborough Historical Society
Click on the map to open a scalable pdf map in a new window

Again Tom was fortunate to come under the influence of the far-sighted Lt. Col. Dr. W. Ernest Jones, 'Inspector General of the Insane' in Victoria. In 1905, with Jones' changing philosophy, the ‘insane’ and ‘lunatics’ treated in the six old asylums were seen as sick patients with mental disorders to be treated in his new hospital. Under his guidance, the Victoria and Melbourne asylums were consolidated into a new hospital built on the suburban parkland of the Mont Park and Strathallan estates. The Mont Park Psychiatric Hospital was established in January 1910 with the first buildings opening in 1912 as four wards of 160 male patients, who would be occupied in farming and gardening. The wards were formed in individual, segregated, self-contained 'pavilions' allocated to specific medical needs, including mental issues. They reflected the changes in attitudes to psychiatric illnesses.

At the outbreak of war the Commonwealth government was obliged to establish treatment and convalescent hospitals for war injuries. In Victoria, those suffering psychiatric conditions, including neurasthenia and shell-shock, and requiring specialised care were incorporated in special wards of No 16 Australian General Hospital at Mont Park. In 1916, these were known as the 'Chronic Wards', until 1918 when they became the responsibility of the Victoria Repatriation Department. In 1918, at Mont Park, Jones introduced Occupational Therapy for the returned serviceman. He sought to assist the rehabilitation of inmates by training them as carpenters, saddlers, tailors to name a few. In response to pressure from returned servicemen's organisations, a Military Mental Hospital was built in 1919 to remove them from the general psychiatric patient population. The shell-shocked patients were separated from the stigma of mental illness. Until 1933, the new wing accommodated 84 military patients who were suffering from psychiatric conditions as a result of their service in World War I, when they were transferred to Commonwealth facilities.

Other buildings were constructed: in 1919 a separate two-storey Administration Block was built with a single-storey kitchen-dining room pavilion at the rear; the free-standing combined church and recreation hall was built between 1927 and 1930 and the early therapeutic farm building was extended.

1821info11f3, sheet 15
2019 map of Mont Park - 76kB jpg 2019 map of Mont Park - 56kB jpg
Above: A 2019 map of Mont Park marking the location of landmarks on the above map, remaining roads in yellow and some known buildings marked red. Click on the map to open a scalable pdf map in a new window
Placeholder Picture

Mont Park entrance 1917  State Library Victoria (SLV) H2010.127/12

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park ward 1917 SLV H2010.127/2

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park ward 1917    SLV H2010.127/2

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park ward 1917 SLV H2010.127/3

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park dining room 1917   SLV H2010.127/4

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park residents 1917   SLV H2010.127/9

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park, interior of ward c.1919    AWM DAX2451

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park, various forms of electrical treatments c.1919    AWM DAX2448

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park, hot air treatments c.1919 AWM DAX2449

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park entrance 2016

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park 'Chronic Ward' pavilions in 2016

Placeholder Picture

Mont Park farm building, dated 1910, in 2014

1821info11f3, sheet 16

In 1920, ten of the twelve wards in the central Mont Park buildings were vacated by the Department of Defence: the remaining two were still occupied by military mental patients. Convalescent ex-servicemen with psychiatric illnesses were sent to the near-by Bundoora Repatriation Hospital in 1924. In 1933 all military mental patients were transferred to Bundoora, and this was where Tom spent the rest of his life.

pdf icon - 3kB gif pdf icon - 3kB gif Click on the icon to read a 2000 word .pdf account of Mont Park's history in a new window.

Sources


A short history of Bundoora

The development of Bundoora is closely associated with Mont Park.

In April 1920, the Commonwealth bought the 600 acres Bundoora Park with its substantial 1899 Queen Anne style federation mansion with various cottages, sheds and stables in the grounds. It was thought to be a suitable site for a convalescent farm for the rehabilitation of ex-servicemen suffering psychiatric and behavioural disorders as a result of their military service. The combined facility became Mont Park Military Mental Wards – a halfway house between treatment and discharge. In 1923, the property was transferred to the Repatriation Commission. In October 1924, the Bundoora Homestead, initially known as Bundoora Convalescent Farm and sometimes the Bundoora Park Curative Farm, was opened as Mental Hospital Ward 2, with Mont Park being Ward 1. It was the first psychiatric facility established in Victoria to provide on-going care and rehabilitation for veterans with an accepted psychiatric illness due to their war service. Ex-servicemen with psychiatric illnesses were assessed at Mont Park and transferred to the adjoining Bundoora Repatriation Hospital for convalescence. Tom transferred between the two depending on his mental state and the need for re-assessment when he had 'escaped' or had gone 'absent without leave'.

Bundoora map 2019 - 111kB jpg Bundoora map 2019 - 111kB jpg
Above: Bundoora map 2019 locating the existing main block and the possible location of the three additional sites Click on the map to open a scalable pdf map in a new window
1821info11f3, sheet 17
Placeholder Picture

Bundoora Convalescent Farm c.1920s   AWM H19366

Placeholder Picture

Bundoora Repatriation Mental Hospital c.1929  AWM H12897

Placeholder Picture

Bundoora Repatriation Mental Hospital c.1930 - billiard table and easy chair   AWM H19373

Placeholder Picture

Bundoora Repatriation Mental Hospital c.1930 - nurse in a ward dining room  AWM H19372

Placeholder Picture

Bundoora Repatriation Mental Hospital, Homestead Annexe c.1936 - patients' dining room  AWM H19371

Placeholder Picture

Bundoora Repatriation Mental Hospital c.1940  AWM H19371

Placeholder Picture

Bundoora Repatriation Mental Hospital 1961 - secure ward   NAA A7342.V13A

Placeholder Picture

Bundoora Repatriation Mental Hospital 1971 - occupational therapy room  NAA A7342.V11

Placeholder Picture

Bundoora Repatriation Mental Hospital, 7 Prospect Hill Drive, in another guise in 2008

In 1933 all the military patients from Mont Park were transferred to the Bundoora Repatriation Mental Hospital. Over the years eight more wards were built, giving the hospital a capacity of 291 beds by 1968, the year after Tom's death.

In 1950 the hospital had 200 patients who had an entitlement for psychiatric care having a disorder due to war service. Many patients were admitted and discharged more than once, some up to 15 times over a period of years. Bundoora closed in 1993.

Sources:

1821info11f3, sheet 18

Absent without leave

There are several records of Tom escaping or, using the military term, of being ‘absent without leave’ for different periods of time. On 24 June 1924 Tom absconded from Bundoora and reached somewhere in the region of Ivanhoe/Alphington, some 11km south of Bundoora. On 30 June 1924 a bill was submitted by Constable Lombard for 15 shillings for the hire of a car from CH Underwood in order to search for Tom and to return him to Bundoora. Advice was sought as to who would pay for the hire. 1

Tom’s longest period of absence without leave was 101 days between 09 June 1938 and 18 September 1938 when the Wodonga police returned him from the town on the New South Wales border, some 305km north of Bundoora. 2 Despite his condition, Tom had managed to travel north and return to the security of his pre-war teaching post. He had survived in the society he knew and perhaps had been happy. Under the Freedom of Information the police reported Tom was 'living in a bag hut against a log and under delusion that he is a famous runner'. 3 He told the police he was training for the Stawell Gift foot race.

Tom's escape map - 54kB jpg The length of this ‘escape’ suggests Tom was able to blend in with his society: being a 'normal' person without manic episodes. At his inquest, Morris Decimanis, a psychiatric male nurse at Bundoora, described Tom as a most polite and clean patient and [who] occasionally went on Day leave. Perhaps his condition worsened and the authorities were informed.

In 1939, Tom escaped from Bundoora to the Drouin area of Gippsland, a distance of 110km. Whilst there, he grew a long beard and a moustache, suggesting the time he was away. He was returned to Royal Park for assessment. 4

His last ‘escape’ was recorded in December 1941. 5

After Tom had 'escaped' he was returned to Royal Park or Mont Park Military Wards for a period of assessment before returning to Bundoora. The time between the two Repatriation Houses varied, presumably depending on Tom’s mental state. On one occasion, in October 1939, an absence resulted in a six week assessment at Royal Park before being returned to Mont Park.
Above: A map showing Tom's escape

To transfer to Bundoora Convalescent Farm, Tom needed to show signs of recovery and suitable for therapy. On 15 December 1923 his transfer to Bundoora was approved but the paper work was not received at Mont Park and on 11 February 1924 it was being 'followed up'. However, Dr. Cade, in charge of Tom’s case, did not feel justified in effecting a transfer at the present time, as I have learned there is no responsible Male official on duty at that Institution during the night … and that this was perhaps, courting trouble. No doubt in the near future … 6 In February 1924, there were still unspecified complications in Tom’s case, but Dr Cade’s decision was overridden.

On 17 January 1940, Lyle Blackman, Tom’s brother, wrote a personal letter addressed Dear Cyril to Cyril Smith, Deputy Commissioner for Repatriation, asking for clarification of Tom’s situation. Tom had been returned to Mont Park after another disappearance, but without any notification to the family. Cyril Smith’s reply assured Lyle that Tom ' Will normally transfer to Bundoora in 7-10 days' and that 'he had Tom’s best interest in his brief'. 7

1821info11f3, sheet 19

An undated circular in early 1923, was sent to the Local Medical Officers 'Re Mental Patients' and the procedures to be adopted to protect soldiers who had returned with mental symptoms:

…[T]he ordinary civilian procedures under the Lunacy Act should be adopted. Returned soldiers are now civilian and these Acts were devised for the protection of the patient and to ensure that the utmost care should be taken to avoid any injustice. It is therefore of the greatest importance that the returned soldier be not deprived of the provisions of the Act intended for his and others protection. Local Medical Officers must accordingly act as in the case of their other patients, and should carry out the procedures set out in the Act for the admission of the patient to the nearest Receiving House, Ward or Hospital for the insane. 8

Provision was made for 'soldiers' on leave to return to the institution by the quickest means without any form or assessment.

Absent with leave

Tom’s NAA Repatriation Record (q.v.) shows several periods of 'home' leave of differing periods of time. In 1922-23 Tom had home leave from Bundoora for three months over Christmas 1922 and again for five months in 1923, returning to Bundoora on New Year’s Eve. In 1930 he had one month 'home' leave followed by six weeks in 1933. It is assumed that he went home to Ballarat. 9

During these periods of absence there were complications with Tom’s pension 10 and subsidence from the Repatriation Department. Various pieces of paper were exchanged clarifying the accounts and agreeing who should pay what amount.

End notes

  1. NAA repatriation pp. 86, 88
  2. ibid p.76
  3. Victoria Freedom of Information - reference pending
  4. ibid - In 1912, his uncle Charles Walter Crompton, a grazier in the Drouin area and his daughter-in-law at Athlone. Tom went on several outings, some with a Russell Stevens to Bendigo and to Drouin areas of Gippsland. Some were with Phillip Connor whose parents had a property at Athlone, near Drouin.
  5. NAA repatriation p.57
  6. ibid pp.92, 94, 95, 96
  7. ibid pp.66, 68
  8. ibid p.99
  9. ibid pp.77, 79, 98
  10. On 1 July 1920, Tom was awarded a pension of 84/- (84 shillings or £4 4 shillings) per fortnight and his mother 40/- (40 shillings or £2) per fortnight in addition to the 20/- per fortnight due to the death in action of her son Leslie Crompton Blackman. (NAA repatriation p.49)

His official status

In 1920, the Rehabilitation Department, in accepting that Tom’s mental state was permanent and war related, took responsibility for his care and wellbeing. Since this had financial implications, pieces of paper were frequently exchanged requiring confirmations that Tom’s mental state was related to war service and to see whether there had been any improvement.

After a period of home leave between 09 November 1922 and 09 February 1923, a letter to the Department of Repatriation, on 02 February 1923, assessed Tom’s situation recording: The outlook as regards mental recovery is unfavourable but he is quiet, inoffensive man he (sic) could live outside a Mental Hospital if proper provisions were made for his care and safe keeping. It is not likely that he will ever be able to support himself. His bodily health is fair but it is likely there is some degeneration of the heart muscles and he also suffers from flatulent dyspepsia.1 Even at this early date the degenerative heart muscles had been flagged but not directly attributed to war injury.

On 27 November 1939, Royal Park were again asked to assess whether Tom’s disability was related to war service, which they confirmed as a war service disability on 05 December 1939. On the same day the Deputy Commission of the Rehabilitation Department accepted responsibility for Tom’s maintenance and asked for him to be transferred back to Repatriation Mental Hospital at Bundoora. 2

1821info11f3, sheet 20

Mont Park reported on 29 July 1941 that the duration of Tom’s stay at Mont Park would be indefinite. 3 Officially, Mont Park recorded:

Since his admission on the 20th January 1942 with a diagnosis of Manic Depressive Psychosis ... 4 5

End notes

  1. NAA repatriation p.101
  2. ibid  pp.71, 72, 73, 75
  3. ibid  p.62
  4. ibid  p.23
  5. Psychosis: Any kind of disordered mental state or mental illness. Severe mental illness, characterized by loss of contact with reality (in the form of delusions and hallucinations) and deterioration of intellectual and social functioning. (OED)

The final years at Bundoora

On 15 August 1951, it was reported that there had been no transfers from Bundoora after 20 January 1941. 1 Tom was still at Bundoora on 07 April 1966 when an application for a truss was made. 2 However, the results of a series of x-rays are recorded showing:

Trachea and mediastinum [Partition between two parts of an organ) in mid line. [This is normal] Plural opacity in left costo-phrenic angle. [Suggests chest infection] Left lung otherwise clear. Irregular opacity due to either injury or infection is present with right infra-clavicular region [This is indeed irregular and the inference would be TB or some established abscess and adhesions and plural thickening are present at base.] No acid fast bacilli seen in sputum. [This rules out TB and is likely to be a chest infection with water on the lungs] 3

There was no change to his chest X-rays during 1967. 4

The records have an official departmental notification of Tom’s death dated 28 November 1967 at 6.30pm. The next of kin Mrs [Marion] Brown (niece) 11 Cashmere (sic) [Kashmira] St, Oakleigh and Mrs [Mavis] Harris (Niece) 6 Airley Road, Glen Iris were informed.

At his inquest, held at Mont Park on 14 December 1967, Morris Decimanis, a psychiatric male nurse at Bundoora and the Medical Officer, Doctor Mok Chee Yu gave deposition that Tom was:

… a most polite and clean patient and occasionally went on Day leave. […] [T]he patient was talkative, full of impractical ideas to making money. He settled down and worked satisfactorily about the hospital and [was] cooperative.
In 1961, he was noted to be in C[ongenital ].H[eart].F[ailure]. with Auricular fibrillation [a quivering or irregular heartbeat] . He responded satisfactorily to treatment and maintained fairly good health.
On 11th March 1966 he was examined by the Medical Officer and placed on the dangerous ill list. Condition improved gradually, then deteriorated and in October 1967 again placed on the dangerously ill list. [H]e suffered a syncopic attack [ caused by low blood pressure and a decreased blood flow to the brain] with delirium and was rather ill. He made a slow recovery.
On the 28th November 1967 patient collapsed in a chair but did not lose consciousness. He was apprehensive, with cold perspiration, in moderate shock and in pain in the lower chest, suggestive of a myocardial Infarction [heart attack]. [He was] examined by the Medical Officer and was placed on the dangerously ill list. Minister of religion and relatives notified. Respiration ceased at 6.30PM on 28th November 1967. Examined by Medical Officer who pronounced life extinct. 5

The autopsy report noted the cause of death as cardiac infarction with bronchopneumonia and old cavities in both lungs, mucus membranes in the oesophagus, widening of the bronchial tubes and acute chronic cystitis. 6

1821info11f3, sheet 21
THIRD SCHEDULE
DEATH IN THE STATE OF VICTORIA
Registered by        Richard CRAG
1 No  No 2882 /67

Description -
2(1) When and where died
 (2) Usual place of residence
3 Name and Surname
   Occupation
4 Sex and age
28th November, 1967,

Bundoora,
Repatriation Mental Hospital,
Bundoora
Walter John Thomas BLACKMAN
Not any
Male, 78 years
5(1) Cause of death
  (2) Duration of last illness
   (3) Legally qualified      medical practitioner by whom certified  and
  (4) When he last saw deceased
Cardiac infarct -

Verdict at inquest held at Mont Park by the Coroner, Mr HW Pascoe, on 14th December, 1967
6 Name and surname of Father and Mother (maiden name, if known), with Occupation William Blackman,
Frances Emily Blackman
Maiden name Crompton
Farmer
7 Signature, Description and Residence of Informant Certified by
HW Pascoe,
Coroner,
Melbourne.
8 (1) Signature of Registration Officer
   (2) Date and
   (3) Where registered
Signed
27th December, 1967.

Melbourne
If burial registered
9  When and where buried
    Undertaker by whom certified
10 Name and Religion of
      Minister or names of
      Witnesses of burial

30th November, 1967.
Cremated at Springvale Crematorium,
A Jensen
L McLennan,
C Ford
11 Where born and how long in the Australian States, stating which Ballarat, Victoria,
78 years in Victoria.
If deceased was married -
12 (1) Where and
    (2) At what age and
    (3) To whom
    (4) Conjugal Condition at Date of Death
13 Issue in Order of Birth, the Name and ages
Not married

7


Making a claim

After Tom’s death his solicitors, Messers Coltman, Wyatt & Anderson, wrote to the Repatriation Department on 20 June 1968 asking whether death was attributable to War Service and asking for certificates to be forwarded to Victorian and Federal Death Duty Authority. 8 The claim was rejected based on the inquest verdict and without the right of appeal. However, the family made a successful appeal approved several years later by Prime Minister, Bob Hawke (in office 1983 to 1991). Bruce Ruxton, RSL Vice President in 1968 may have been involved.

1821info11f3, sheet 22

End notes

  1. NAA repatriation p.45
  2. ibid p.42
  3. ibid pp.36,40,41 Medical interpretation by Dr James Crompton
  4. ibid pp.20,32
  5. ibid pp.24,25
  6. ibid p.22
  7. ibid p.27
  8. ibid p.26
Tom Blackman's memorial Springvale Cemetery - 42kB jpg Tom was cremated on 30 November 1967, two days after his death.

Left: Tom Blackman's Australian War Graves memorial Springvale Cemetery, held in perpetuity at Brind, Wall Q, Niche 200 - November 2015 Author

1821info11f3, sheet 23

His will

Placeholder Picture

The cover of Tom's estate papers

Placeholder Picture

Page 2 of Tom's estate papers showing his worth and his legatees

Placeholder Picture

Tom's will - page 3

Placeholder Picture

Tom's will - final page

Placeholder Picture

Tom's assets - page 1

Placeholder Picture

Tom's assets - page 2

Placeholder Picture

Tom's letters of administration - page 1

Placeholder Picture

Tom's letters of administration - page 2

Placeholder Picture

Tom's probate - page 1

Placeholder Picture

Tom's probate - page 2

Placeholder Picture

Tom's probate - page 3

Placeholder Picture

Tom's probate - page 4


Tom Blackman commemorated in Ballarat

Tom Blackman's Arch of Victory marker Nov 2015 - 18kB jpg Left: Tom BLACKMAN's Arch of Victory marker in November 2015 - Author
1821info11f3, sheet 24
Right: Positioned between two carriageways, Tom BLACKMAN's marker number 136 in November 2015 - Author Tom Blackman's Avenue of Honour marker 2015 - 96kB jpg
Arch of Victory, Ballarat November 2015 - 50kB jpg Left: Arch of Victory, Ballarat November 2015 - Author
1821info11f3, sheet 25

Hoverbox Photo Gallery - Ballarat Avenue of Honour c.1920
This feature does not function correctly on phones and tablets

1 Early plantings in the Ballarat Avenue of Honor, c1920. Courtesy Federation University Historical Collection [Cat.No.1279].   2 The Ballarat Arch of Victory showing early plantings in the Ballarat Avenue of Honor, c1920. Courtesy Federation University Historical Collection [Cat.No.19012].
1   2  
Ballarat Avenue of Honor, c1920 - 33kB jpg Ballarat Avenue of Honor, c1920 - 33kB Ballarat Arch of Victory c.1920 - 36kB jpg Ballarat Arch of Victory - 36kB jpg

View YouTube video of the one hundredth anniversary commemoration of Ballarat's Victory Arch and Avenue of Honour

Blackman page Shrine Memorial Book - 45kB jpg Left: Blackman page in Melbourne's Shrine of Remembrance Memorial Book
1821info11f3, sheet 26
Right: The Shrine of Remembrance, Melbourne 2015 - Author Shrine of Remberance, Melbourne 2015 - 64kB jpg

A personal postscript by Heather Schoffelen, Tom’s great niece

My memories of Tom are probably thin as it was between 1955 and 1961 when we lived at Point Lonsdale. I don’t know exact dates and I only remember him visiting twice during that time. My siblings and myself were usually dressed in very casual clothes, shorts, T-shirt’s, sandals or bare feet, so to see an older man wearing a black suit, white shirt, black polished shoes and black hat was unusual for youngsters who spent many hours at the beach or climbing the sand dunes.
Aunt Marion and Uncle Horrie (Horace Brown) would collect Tom from his accommodation at Bundoora, about 130kms. from Point Lonsdale. He arrived with a brown paper bag filled with sweets for us children. A real treat and no doubt organised by our generous and loving Marion.
Tom was very interested in looking around his surroundings, observing us children as we played but he said very little. It could have been because of his health restrictions or that he was listening to his nieces and their husbands. Tom enjoyed walking around the premises, stopping to just look around, then retracing his steps. He was a gentle man, inoffensive, polite.
Marion and Horrie often took Tom on outings; he loved being in the car. When Horrie was not able to visit Tom, Marion and her two daughters would travel by bus, train and tram to his home at Bundoora, a trip of an hour and a half each way. Marion would prompt Tom by speaking of his youth and news of his family. She would encourage Tom to participate in activities, walk in the garden and help where he could. 1

End notes

  1. By email 10 October 2019

1821info11f3, sheet 27

Sources


Back to top
Previous - 2kB jpg Next - 2kB jpg To Caleb Crompton's tree
Use portrait to print - 5kB gif
This page was created by Richard Crompton
and maintained by Chris Glass
Frontpage icon - 4kB jpg Version A8
Updated 09 June 2023